커뮤니티

수식 부탁드립니다.

프로필 이미지
제이디1
2022-07-06 18:43:12
1302
글번호 160508
답변완료
Input:전환비율(5); input : StartTime(090000),EndTime(055500); Input :익절(25),손절(33),당일수익(45),당일손실(50); Var : N1(0),dayPl(0),Tcond(false),Xcond(false); Var : j(0),jj(0),HH(0),LL(0),hiBar(0),loBar(0),최종꼭지점(""),처리구분(""); var : TL1(0),Text1(0),ADXV1(0),tl2(0),tl3(0),tx2(0),tx3(0),t(0); Array:고[10,4](0),저[10,4](0); HH = H; LL = L; If Index == 0 Then { 고[1,1] = HH; 고[1,2] = 0; 고[1,3] = sDate; 고[1,4] = sTime; 저[1,1] = LL; 저[1,2] = 0; 저[1,3] = sDate; 저[1,4] = sTime; } If Index > 0 Then { hiBar = hiBar + 1; loBar = loBar + 1; } If HH[hiBar] < HH Then hiBar = 0; If LL[loBar] > LL Then loBar = 0; Condition1 = 저[1,1] * (1 + (전환비율/100)) < HH and hiBar == 0; Condition2 = 고[1,1] * (1 - (전환비율/100)) > LL and loBar == 0; 처리구분 = ""; If Condition1 and Condition2 Then // 고점과 저점 조건 동시 만족 { If 최종꼭지점 == "저점" Then { If 저[1,1] > LL Then 처리구분 = "저점처리"; Else 처리구분 = "고점처리"; } Else If 최종꼭지점 == "고점" Then { If 고[1,1] < HH Then 처리구분 = "고점처리"; Else 처리구분 = "저점처리"; } } Else If Condition1 Then 처리구분 = "고점처리"; Else If Condition2 Then 처리구분 = "저점처리"; If 처리구분 == "고점처리" Then { T = 1; If 최종꼭지점 == "저점" Then { TL_SetEnd(TL2,저[1,3],저[1,4],고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX2,저[1,3],저[1,4],고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); For j = 10 DownTo 2 { For jj = 1 To 4 { 고[j,jj] = 고[j-1,jj]; } } 고[1,1] = HH[hiBar]; 고[1,2] = Index - hiBar; 고[1,3] = sDate[hiBar]; 고[1,4] = sTime[hiBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL1 = TL_New(저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1],고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]); TL_SetSize(TL1,1); TL_SetColor(TL1,RED); TL2 = TL_New(고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)) ,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetColor(TL2,Cyan); TL_SetStyle(TL2,3); Tx2 = Text_New(NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),NumToStr(고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),2)); Text_SetColor(Tx2,Cyan); } Else If 고[1,1] < HH[hiBar] Then // 1번 고점보다 높은 고가 출현 { 고[1,1] = HH[hiBar]; 고[1,2] = Index - hiBar; 고[1,3] = sDate[hiBar]; 고[1,4] = sTime[hiBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL_SetEnd(TL1,고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]); TL_SetBegin(TL2,고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]* (1-(전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetString(TX2,NumToStr(고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),2)); } 최종꼭지점 = "고점"; } If 처리구분 == "저점처리" Then { t = -1; If 최종꼭지점 == "고점" Then { TL_SetEnd(TL3,고[1,3],고[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX3,고[1,3],고[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); For j = 10 DownTo 2 { For jj = 1 To 4 { 저[j,jj] = 저[j-1,jj]; } } 저[1,1] = LL[loBar]; 저[1,2] = Index - loBar; 저[1,3] = sDate[loBar]; 저[1,4] = sTime[loBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL1 = TL_New(고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1],저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]); TL_SetSize(TL1,1); TL_SetColor(TL1,BLUE); TL3 = TL_New(저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetColor(TL3,Magenta); TL_SetStyle(TL3,3); TX3 = Text_New(NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),NumToStr(저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),2)); Text_SetColor(TX3,Magenta); } Else If 저[1,1] > LL[loBar] Then { 저[1,1] = LL[loBar]; 저[1,2] = Index - loBar; 저[1,3] = sDate[loBar]; 저[1,4] = sTime[loBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL_SetEnd(TL1,저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]); TL_SetBegin(TL3,저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetString(TX3,NumToStr(저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),2)); } 최종꼭지점 = "저점"; } TL_SetEnd(TL2,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX2,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetEnd(TL3,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX3,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); IF Endtime > starttime Then SetStopEndofday(Endtime); Else { if sDate != sDate[1] Then SetStopEndofday(Endtime); } if (sdate != sdate[1] and stime >= EndTime) or (sdate == sdate[1] and stime >= EndTime and stime[1] < EndTime) Then Tcond = False; if (sdate != sdate[1] and stime >= StartTime) or (sdate == sdate[1] and stime >= StartTime and stime[1] < StartTime) Then { Tcond = true; Xcond = false; N1 = NetProfit; IF Endtime <= starttime Then { SetStopEndofday(0); } } daypl = NetProfit-N1; if TotalTrades > TotalTrades[1] then { if daypl >= 당일수익 or daypl <= -당일손실 Then Xcond = true; if (IsExitName("dbp",1) == true or IsExitName("dbl",1) == true or IsExitName("dsp",1) == true or IsExitName("dsl",1) == true) then Xcond = true; } if Tcond == true and Xcond == false then { if MarketPosition >= 0 and T == 1 and L > 고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) Then Sell("s",AtStop,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100))); if MarketPosition <= 0 and T == -1 and H < 저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) Then Buy("b",AtStop,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100))); } if MarketPosition == 1 then { ExitLong("dbp",atlimit,EntryPrice+((당일수익-daypl)/CurrentContracts)); ExitLong("dbl",AtStop,EntryPrice-((당일손실+daypl)/CurrentContracts)); } if MarketPosition == -1 then { ExitShort("dsp",atlimit,EntryPrice-((당일수익-daypl)/CurrentContracts)); ExitShort("dsl",AtStop,EntryPrice+((당일손실+daypl)/CurrentContracts)); } SetStopProfittarget(익절,PointStop); SetStopLoss(손절,PointStop); 위 수식에서 매수매도 진입을 정반대로 하는 수식을 만들고 싶어서 188번, 190번 줄에 sell, buy만 바꿨더니 이상하게 나오네요.. 분홍선, 파란선 나올때마다 분홍선에서 매도, 파란선에서 매수 하고 싶은데, 어떨때는 나오고 어떨때는 진입을 늦게하거나 몇개 건너띄고 진입하거나, 선이 없는데서 진입하기도 하네요?
시스템
답변 1
프로필 이미지

예스스탁 예스스탁 답변

2022-07-07 09:21:21

안녕하세요 예스스탁입니다. Input:전환비율(5); input : StartTime(090000),EndTime(055500); Input :익절(25),손절(33),당일수익(45),당일손실(50); Var : N1(0),dayPl(0),Tcond(false),Xcond(false); Var : j(0),jj(0),HH(0),LL(0),hiBar(0),loBar(0),최종꼭지점(""),처리구분(""); var : TL1(0),Text1(0),ADXV1(0),tl2(0),tl3(0),tx2(0),tx3(0),t(0); Array:고[10,4](0),저[10,4](0); HH = H; LL = L; If Index == 0 Then { 고[1,1] = HH; 고[1,2] = 0; 고[1,3] = sDate; 고[1,4] = sTime; 저[1,1] = LL; 저[1,2] = 0; 저[1,3] = sDate; 저[1,4] = sTime; } If Index > 0 Then { hiBar = hiBar + 1; loBar = loBar + 1; } If HH[hiBar] < HH Then hiBar = 0; If LL[loBar] > LL Then loBar = 0; Condition1 = 저[1,1] * (1 + (전환비율/100)) < HH and hiBar == 0; Condition2 = 고[1,1] * (1 - (전환비율/100)) > LL and loBar == 0; 처리구분 = ""; If Condition1 and Condition2 Then // 고점과 저점 조건 동시 만족 { If 최종꼭지점 == "저점" Then { If 저[1,1] > LL Then 처리구분 = "저점처리"; Else 처리구분 = "고점처리"; } Else If 최종꼭지점 == "고점" Then { If 고[1,1] < HH Then 처리구분 = "고점처리"; Else 처리구분 = "저점처리"; } } Else If Condition1 Then 처리구분 = "고점처리"; Else If Condition2 Then 처리구분 = "저점처리"; If 처리구분 == "고점처리" Then { T = 1; If 최종꼭지점 == "저점" Then { TL_SetEnd(TL2,저[1,3],저[1,4],고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX2,저[1,3],저[1,4],고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); For j = 10 DownTo 2 { For jj = 1 To 4 { 고[j,jj] = 고[j-1,jj]; } } 고[1,1] = HH[hiBar]; 고[1,2] = Index - hiBar; 고[1,3] = sDate[hiBar]; 고[1,4] = sTime[hiBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL1 = TL_New(저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1],고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]); TL_SetSize(TL1,1); TL_SetColor(TL1,RED); TL2 = TL_New(고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)) ,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetColor(TL2,Cyan); TL_SetStyle(TL2,3); Tx2 = Text_New(NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),NumToStr(고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),2)); Text_SetColor(Tx2,Cyan); } Else If 고[1,1] < HH[hiBar] Then // 1번 고점보다 높은 고가 출현 { 고[1,1] = HH[hiBar]; 고[1,2] = Index - hiBar; 고[1,3] = sDate[hiBar]; 고[1,4] = sTime[hiBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL_SetEnd(TL1,고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]); TL_SetBegin(TL2,고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]* (1-(전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetString(TX2,NumToStr(고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),2)); } 최종꼭지점 = "고점"; } If 처리구분 == "저점처리" Then { t = -1; If 최종꼭지점 == "고점" Then { TL_SetEnd(TL3,고[1,3],고[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX3,고[1,3],고[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); For j = 10 DownTo 2 { For jj = 1 To 4 { 저[j,jj] = 저[j-1,jj]; } } 저[1,1] = LL[loBar]; 저[1,2] = Index - loBar; 저[1,3] = sDate[loBar]; 저[1,4] = sTime[loBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL1 = TL_New(고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1],저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]); TL_SetSize(TL1,1); TL_SetColor(TL1,BLUE); TL3 = TL_New(저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetColor(TL3,Magenta); TL_SetStyle(TL3,3); TX3 = Text_New(NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),NumToStr(저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),2)); Text_SetColor(TX3,Magenta); } Else If 저[1,1] > LL[loBar] Then { 저[1,1] = LL[loBar]; 저[1,2] = Index - loBar; 저[1,3] = sDate[loBar]; 저[1,4] = sTime[loBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL_SetEnd(TL1,저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]); TL_SetBegin(TL3,저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetString(TX3,NumToStr(저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),2)); } 최종꼭지점 = "저점"; } TL_SetEnd(TL2,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX2,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetEnd(TL3,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX3,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); IF Endtime > starttime Then SetStopEndofday(Endtime); Else { if sDate != sDate[1] Then SetStopEndofday(Endtime); } if (sdate != sdate[1] and stime >= EndTime) or (sdate == sdate[1] and stime >= EndTime and stime[1] < EndTime) Then Tcond = False; if (sdate != sdate[1] and stime >= StartTime) or (sdate == sdate[1] and stime >= StartTime and stime[1] < StartTime) Then { Tcond = true; Xcond = false; N1 = NetProfit; IF Endtime <= starttime Then { SetStopEndofday(0); } } daypl = NetProfit-N1; if TotalTrades > TotalTrades[1] then { if daypl >= 당일수익 or daypl <= -당일손실 Then Xcond = true; if (IsExitName("dbp",1) == true or IsExitName("dbl",1) == true or IsExitName("dsp",1) == true or IsExitName("dsl",1) == true) then Xcond = true; } if Tcond == true and Xcond == false then { if MarketPosition >= 0 and T == 1 and L > 고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) Then Buy("s",AtLimit,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100))); if MarketPosition <= 0 and T == -1 and H < 저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) Then Sell("s",AtLimit,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100))); } if MarketPosition == 1 then { ExitLong("dbp",atlimit,EntryPrice+((당일수익-daypl)/CurrentContracts)); ExitLong("dbl",AtStop,EntryPrice-((당일손실+daypl)/CurrentContracts)); } if MarketPosition == -1 then { ExitShort("dsp",atlimit,EntryPrice-((당일수익-daypl)/CurrentContracts)); ExitShort("dsl",AtStop,EntryPrice+((당일손실+daypl)/CurrentContracts)); } SetStopProfittarget(익절,PointStop); SetStopLoss(손절,PointStop); 즐거운 하루되세요 > 제이디1 님이 쓴 글입니다. > 제목 : 수식 부탁드립니다. > Input:전환비율(5); input : StartTime(090000),EndTime(055500); Input :익절(25),손절(33),당일수익(45),당일손실(50); Var : N1(0),dayPl(0),Tcond(false),Xcond(false); Var : j(0),jj(0),HH(0),LL(0),hiBar(0),loBar(0),최종꼭지점(""),처리구분(""); var : TL1(0),Text1(0),ADXV1(0),tl2(0),tl3(0),tx2(0),tx3(0),t(0); Array:고[10,4](0),저[10,4](0); HH = H; LL = L; If Index == 0 Then { 고[1,1] = HH; 고[1,2] = 0; 고[1,3] = sDate; 고[1,4] = sTime; 저[1,1] = LL; 저[1,2] = 0; 저[1,3] = sDate; 저[1,4] = sTime; } If Index > 0 Then { hiBar = hiBar + 1; loBar = loBar + 1; } If HH[hiBar] < HH Then hiBar = 0; If LL[loBar] > LL Then loBar = 0; Condition1 = 저[1,1] * (1 + (전환비율/100)) < HH and hiBar == 0; Condition2 = 고[1,1] * (1 - (전환비율/100)) > LL and loBar == 0; 처리구분 = ""; If Condition1 and Condition2 Then // 고점과 저점 조건 동시 만족 { If 최종꼭지점 == "저점" Then { If 저[1,1] > LL Then 처리구분 = "저점처리"; Else 처리구분 = "고점처리"; } Else If 최종꼭지점 == "고점" Then { If 고[1,1] < HH Then 처리구분 = "고점처리"; Else 처리구분 = "저점처리"; } } Else If Condition1 Then 처리구분 = "고점처리"; Else If Condition2 Then 처리구분 = "저점처리"; If 처리구분 == "고점처리" Then { T = 1; If 최종꼭지점 == "저점" Then { TL_SetEnd(TL2,저[1,3],저[1,4],고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX2,저[1,3],저[1,4],고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); For j = 10 DownTo 2 { For jj = 1 To 4 { 고[j,jj] = 고[j-1,jj]; } } 고[1,1] = HH[hiBar]; 고[1,2] = Index - hiBar; 고[1,3] = sDate[hiBar]; 고[1,4] = sTime[hiBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL1 = TL_New(저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1],고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]); TL_SetSize(TL1,1); TL_SetColor(TL1,RED); TL2 = TL_New(고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)) ,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetColor(TL2,Cyan); TL_SetStyle(TL2,3); Tx2 = Text_New(NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),NumToStr(고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),2)); Text_SetColor(Tx2,Cyan); } Else If 고[1,1] < HH[hiBar] Then // 1번 고점보다 높은 고가 출현 { 고[1,1] = HH[hiBar]; 고[1,2] = Index - hiBar; 고[1,3] = sDate[hiBar]; 고[1,4] = sTime[hiBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL_SetEnd(TL1,고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]); TL_SetBegin(TL2,고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1]* (1-(전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetString(TX2,NumToStr(고[1,1]*(1-(전환비율/100)),2)); } 최종꼭지점 = "고점"; } If 처리구분 == "저점처리" Then { t = -1; If 최종꼭지점 == "고점" Then { TL_SetEnd(TL3,고[1,3],고[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX3,고[1,3],고[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); For j = 10 DownTo 2 { For jj = 1 To 4 { 저[j,jj] = 저[j-1,jj]; } } 저[1,1] = LL[loBar]; 저[1,2] = Index - loBar; 저[1,3] = sDate[loBar]; 저[1,4] = sTime[loBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL1 = TL_New(고[1,3],고[1,4],고[1,1],저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]); TL_SetSize(TL1,1); TL_SetColor(TL1,BLUE); TL3 = TL_New(저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetColor(TL3,Magenta); TL_SetStyle(TL3,3); TX3 = Text_New(NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),NumToStr(저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),2)); Text_SetColor(TX3,Magenta); } Else If 저[1,1] > LL[loBar] Then { 저[1,1] = LL[loBar]; 저[1,2] = Index - loBar; 저[1,3] = sDate[loBar]; 저[1,4] = sTime[loBar]; hiBar = -1; loBar = -1; TL_SetEnd(TL1,저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]); TL_SetBegin(TL3,저[1,3],저[1,4],저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetString(TX3,NumToStr(저[1,1]*(1+(전환비율/100)),2)); } 최종꼭지점 = "저점"; } TL_SetEnd(TL2,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX2,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) ); TL_SetEnd(TL3,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); Text_SetLocation(TX3,NextBarSdate,NextBarStime,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) ); IF Endtime > starttime Then SetStopEndofday(Endtime); Else { if sDate != sDate[1] Then SetStopEndofday(Endtime); } if (sdate != sdate[1] and stime >= EndTime) or (sdate == sdate[1] and stime >= EndTime and stime[1] < EndTime) Then Tcond = False; if (sdate != sdate[1] and stime >= StartTime) or (sdate == sdate[1] and stime >= StartTime and stime[1] < StartTime) Then { Tcond = true; Xcond = false; N1 = NetProfit; IF Endtime <= starttime Then { SetStopEndofday(0); } } daypl = NetProfit-N1; if TotalTrades > TotalTrades[1] then { if daypl >= 당일수익 or daypl <= -당일손실 Then Xcond = true; if (IsExitName("dbp",1) == true or IsExitName("dbl",1) == true or IsExitName("dsp",1) == true or IsExitName("dsl",1) == true) then Xcond = true; } if Tcond == true and Xcond == false then { if MarketPosition >= 0 and T == 1 and L > 고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100)) Then Sell("s",AtStop,고[1,1]* (1 - (전환비율/100))); if MarketPosition <= 0 and T == -1 and H < 저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100)) Then Buy("b",AtStop,저[1,1]* (1 + (전환비율/100))); } if MarketPosition == 1 then { ExitLong("dbp",atlimit,EntryPrice+((당일수익-daypl)/CurrentContracts)); ExitLong("dbl",AtStop,EntryPrice-((당일손실+daypl)/CurrentContracts)); } if MarketPosition == -1 then { ExitShort("dsp",atlimit,EntryPrice-((당일수익-daypl)/CurrentContracts)); ExitShort("dsl",AtStop,EntryPrice+((당일손실+daypl)/CurrentContracts)); } SetStopProfittarget(익절,PointStop); SetStopLoss(손절,PointStop); 위 수식에서 매수매도 진입을 정반대로 하는 수식을 만들고 싶어서 188번, 190번 줄에 sell, buy만 바꿨더니 이상하게 나오네요.. 분홍선, 파란선 나올때마다 분홍선에서 매도, 파란선에서 매수 하고 싶은데, 어떨때는 나오고 어떨때는 진입을 늦게하거나 몇개 건너띄고 진입하거나, 선이 없는데서 진입하기도 하네요?